AM vs SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF WEST PAKISTAN, — 1971 PLC 212

Citation: 1971 PLC 212

Court: Civil Services Tribunal

Year: 1971

Decision Date: 1971-05-13

Parties: AM vs SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF WEST PAKISTAN,

Headnotes

Case cited as 1971 PLC 212

Judgment Text

Court Name: Civil Services Tribunal Judge(s): S. A. Mahmood, Ashfaq Ali Khan, Bashir Ahmad Khan Title: AM vs SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF WEST PAKISTAN, Case No.: Case No. 307/280 Date of Judgment:1971-05-13 Reported As: 1971 PLC 212 [C.S.T.] Result: order made Judgment ORDER S. A. MAHMOOD (CHAIRMAN).--By this appeal under Sec--tion 4(1) of the West Pakistan Civil Services (Appellate Tribunals) Ordinance, 1969, Mr. Muhammad Aslam, appellant, who is an Assistant in the office of Chief Engineer, Irrigation, Lahore, claims seniority over Messrs Muhammad Rafique, Yahya Ali Khan, Abdar Rashid and Mehraj Dingy respondents 3 to 6 who are also Assistants in the same office. He prays that his seniority may be corrected and his name placed in the seniority list above those of the respondents. The Secretary to Government of the Punjab and Chief Engineer, Irrigation are represented before us by Mr. A. G. Humayyun, Government Pleader. Mr. Muhammad Rafiaue, respondent No. 3 is represented by Mr. Muhammad Tufail Basra, Advocate. The remaining three respondents are present in person, The learned counsel for Mr. Muhammad Rafique, respondent bas raised three preliminary objections. The first is that as the impugned seniority list issued on 4-3-1970 was withdrawn by the Superintending Engineer (Headquarters), who is the competent authority this appeal has become in fructuous. As to this contention, it has been pointed out by the learned counsel for the appellant that the impugned list has been…

Read the full judgment on Al Wakeelo — Pakistan's AI-powered legal research platform.