Al Wakeelo logo

Al Wakeelo

Your Digital Lawyer, Always on Duty

Initializing Secure Chambers

1924 PCRLJ 2119

ABDUL GHAFOOR and 6 others vs THE STATE

Petitioner: ABDUL GHAFOOR and 6 others VS Respondent: THE STATE

Court: Sindh High Court Decision Date: 1984-03-20

Which judgment is this?

ABDUL GHAFOOR and 6 others vs THE STATE (1924 PCRLJ 2119) — Sindh High Court, decided 1984-03-20. Read the available judgment text and citation references on Al Wakeelo.

How can I cite and verify this judgment?

Use the case title and recorded citation, court and decision date above. Read the original judgment before relying on a headnote or extracted text. Citation links alone do not establish that a decision remains good law. Al Wakeelo is a research platform, not the issuing court.

Permanent judgment link

Missing or incorrect information? Report a record issue.

Full Judgment Text & Judicial Ruling

Court Name: Sindh High Court Judge(s): Abdul Hayee Qureshi, Z.C. Valiani Title: ABDUL GHAFOOR and 6 others vs THE STATE Case No.: Criminal Appeal No,225 of 1981 Date of Judgment:1984-03-20 Reported As: 1924 P Cr. L J 2119 Result: Order accordingly

JUDGMENT

JUDGMENT ' Abdul Hayee Kureshi, C.Jr- In Sessions Case No,252/1981 (originally of the Court of Sessions Judge, Sanghar) thirteen person, namely, Ghulam Shabbir Khalyar, lmdadullah Unar, Shah Nawaz Junejo, Muhammad Hassan, Ch. Muhammad Yaqoob, Shah Muhammad, Abdul Ghafoor, Muhammad Aslam, Noor Muhammad, Muhammad Muneer, Ghulam Qassim, Mir Muhammad Khan Lashari and Dr. Muhammad Afzal were placed on trial for offences under section 302 read with sections 34/109, 120B, P.P.C/364 read with sections 109/201/218/197, P.P.C. Three other persons, namely, Sobo, Muhammad Yousuf and Ali Nawaz, all Police Constables of Sanghar Police Station, were also involved in that case, but they were not tried, as they were dead. Jam Sadiq Ali, a former Minister of the Government of Sind, and Police Constable Lal Khan of Sanghar Police Station, were shown as absconders. After the examination of all evidence, but before the announcement of judgment, Ghulam Shabbir and Imdadullah, who were respectively the. Superintendent of Police, and Deputy Commissioner, Sanghar, at the relevant time, had also absconded. By the judgment, dated 18th November, 1981, by Mr. Qadeer Muhammad Qureshi, who was appointed exofficio Additional Sessions Judge, Hyderabad, for trial of this case, accused Shah Nawaz, Muhammad Hassan and Dr. Muhammad Afzal were acquitted, whereas the remaining accused were convicted. Accused Abdul Ghafoor, Shah Muhammad, Muhammad Aslam, Noor Muhammad, Muhammad Muneer and Ch. Muhammad Yaqoob were convicted under section 302/34, P.P.C., whereas accused Ghulam Qassim was convicted under section 302/109 P.P.C. Each one of them was sentenced to death. Accused Muhammad Yaqoob was also convicted under section 201, P.P.C. And sentenced to R.I. For three years, and pay a fine of Rs,1,000(in default R.I. For three months) and also under section 218, P.P.C. And sentenced to two years' R.I. In addition, accused Muhammad Yaqoob and accused Shah

---

## Page 2

Muhammad (now dead) were ordered to pay compensation of Rs, 5,000 each (in default R.I. For one year), whereas accused Abdul Ghafoor, Aslam, Noor Muhammad, Muhammad Muneer and Ghulam Qassim were also ordered to pay compensation of Rs, 2,000 each (in default R.I. For six months). Such order of compensation does not indicate as to whom was compensation payable. These 7 accused persons have filed an appeal through Mr. Allahdino Memon. Accused Muhammad Aslam was convicted under section 302/34, P.P.C. And sentenced to death, whereas accused Mir Muhammad was convicted under section 218, P.P.0 and sentenced to R.I. For two years. These two accused, namely, Muhammad Aslam and Noor Muhammad have also filed separate appeals through Mr. Muhammad Hayat Junejo. The case for confirmation of the sentence of death imposed on each one of the persons, who were so sentenced, has been submitted to this Court. Complainant Muhammad Yaqoob is aggrieved by reason of acquittal of accused Shah Nawaz and Muhammad Aslam, and he has filed a Revision Application to challenge such acquittal. State has also filed an acquittal appeal to challenge the acquittal of accused Shah Nawaz, Muhammad Hassan and Dr. Afzal. ' The confirmation case, appeals by convicted accused, the acquittal appeal filed by State, and the Criminal Revision Application filed by complainant Muhammad Yaqoob have been heard together. We may state that the acquittal appeal filed by State was not pressed by Mr. Azizullah K. Shaikh, appearing as special Public Prosecutor, on behalf of the State. Complainant Muhammad Yaqoob made no appearance in the Revision Application that was filed to challenge the acquittal of Shah Nawaz and Muhammad Hassan. ' We have heard Mr. Muhammad Hayat Junejo, for appellants Muhammad Aslam (Criminal Appeal No, 224/1981), Muhammad Yaqoob (Criminal Appeal No, 225/1981), and Mir Muhammad Lashari (Criminal Appeal No, 220/1981). We have also heard Mr. Abdul Qadir Halepota, for appellant, Ghulam Qassim (Criminal Appeal No, 225/1981), and Mr. Allahdino Memon for appellants Abdul Ghafoor, Noor Muhammad and Muhammad Muneer (Criminal Appeal No, 225/1981). We have also heard Mr. Abdur Rasool Agha, who had appeared for the acquitted accused Shah Nawaz and Muhammad Hassan (Acquittal Appeal No, 63/1982), and Mr. Abdul Wahab Khan for acquitted accused Dr. Muhammad Afzal (Acquittal Appeal No, 63/1982). ' The prosecution story is mainly disclosed by complainant Muhammad Yaqoob (P.W.3) and Head Constable Muhammad Aslam (P.W.12). It is stated that one Ali Bux Junejo, a prominent figure of Sanghar, and friend of absconding accused Jam Sadiq Ali, was murdered on 5th October, 1973 in Sanghar Town. A report to that effect was lodged, and investigation was started by the Sanghar Police, headed by Ch. Muhammad Yaqoob. Since the assailants were not arrested, a curfew was imposed in the town of Sanghar, presumably to comb the town for arrest of the assailants. A large number of persons were apprehended and brought to Sanghar Police Station. It is then said that even absconder Jam Sadiq Ali, a then sitting Provincial Minister, came to Sanghar with an intention "to supervise the investigation of the case" as stated by complainant Muhammad Yaqoob. It is then stated that, on the morning of the following day, viz. 6th October, 1973, approver Muhammad Aslam, who was a Head Constable at the Sanghar Police Station, was asked by accused Ch. Yaqoob, the S.H.O. Of the said Police Station, to go to the office of the Deputy Commissioner and District Magistrate, Sanghar, viz. Lmdadullah Unar, and meet the Sharistedar of the said Magistrate. The approver, Muhammad Aslam, states that he was told by accused S.H.O. Ch. Yaqoob that six people will be handed over to him by the Sharistedar of the said Court, and they should be brought to Sanghar Police Station. Approver Muhammad Aslam, alongwith four constables, two out of whom were Soba Khan and Ali Nawaz, went in a van to the office of the District Magistrate, where they met Abdur Rashid, his Sharistedar (P.W.I7), and the latter sent for six persons, who were sitting outside the office in the compound of the Court. It is stated that Imdadullah Unar was also sitting in the Court, and he directed approver Aslam to take those six persons to the Police Station, who were

---

## Page 3

accordingly handcuffed by approver Aslam, and brought to the van, which was standing out side. The names of these six persons, who are the deceased in this case, are Umad Ali Sanjarani, Mehrab Sanjarani, Ali Sher Shah, Hamzo, Alidad alias Dad and Jan Muhammad Sanjarani. It is stated that four, out of these persons, were accused in one case under the Goonda Act, and two more were accused in another case, and that both these cases were fixed in the Court of the District Magistrate for hearing on 6th October, 1973. At the time when the six deceased were given in custody of approver Aslam, Sadoro (P.W.5), who was the brother of deceased Mehrab and a brother-in-law of deceased Umad Ali, was present in the Court of the District Magistrate, as he had also come with his relative to the Court. Muhammad Hassan was also present there. This witness also states that all the six deceased persons were called in the Court Room and, thereafter, they came out in handcuffs. On asking deceased Mehrab told them that they had been arrested under the orders of the District Magistrate, who had directed their being taken to the Police Station. The six deceased persons were brought to the Police Station, and their custody was handed over to accused Muhammad Yaqoob, who was S.H.O. Of Sanghar Police Station. At Sanghar Police Station, several persons were found to be sitting, and Sadoro identified at least two out of those persons to be Ghazi Khan (P.W.6) and Rakhial. It is stated that these two persons were also the followers of Pir Sahib Pagaro. The story then is that, at about mid-day, the six deceased persons were put in the lock-up. ' The next leg of the story is that, at about sunset time on the same day, accused Muhammad Yaqoob came, alongwith some Policemen of Sanghar Police Station, and directed that the six deceased be taken out of the lock-up, from where they were taken to a quarter within the Police Station compound, and approver Muhammad Aslam states that these six persons were taken to that quarter for the purpose of being beaten, so that confession should be extorted. It is in evidence that such quarters are bachelor quarters in the Police Station, and are located in the northeast corner of the compound of the Police Station. Approver Muhammad Aslam further states that he was told by accused Muhammad Yaqoob that information in regard to death of Ali Bux should be extorted from these six persons, so that such information could be conveyed to Jam Sadiq Ali, who was then a Minister, and had also come to Sanghar Police Station for such purpose. The approver, therefore, discloses that he, alongwith other Policemen, started beating the deceased with sticks, shoes, fists, slaps, and leather hunter. The story discloses that the beating was so severe that fierce cries were raised, which were even heard by such persons, who had been detained at the main building of the Police Station. It is stated that two, out of these six persons, became unconscious after beating, which continued for more than an hour, and thereafter these two persons were carried by the Policemen on their shoulders and brought back to the lock-up, where they were kept. In fact, Ghazi Khan, who was present at the Police Station, having been called as a uspect, has stated that these two persons, namely Mehrab and Umad were in such bad condition that he thought that they were dead. In regard to the remaining four, it is stated that some injuries have been caused to them also. ' The next link in the story is that, at about 11.00 p.m. On 6th October, 1973, approver Aslam was called from his house by S.H.O. Muhammad Yagoob, and he went to the Police Station, when he was told that the six persons had to be taken to Khipro Sub-Jail, and a police party had also been formed for such purpose. This party consisted of A.S.!. Shah Muhammad, Head Constable Abdul Ghafoor, Constables Noor Muhammad, Muhammad Aslam, Muhammad Munir, Lal Khan, Muhammad Yousuf, Soba Khan and Ali Nawaz. It is stated that accused S.H.O. Muhammad Yaqoob had told this police party to take arms and ammunition from Head Constable Khaliluddin (P.W.11), and entry was made in the Station diary maintained at Sanghar Police Station (Exh. 42) at 11-00 p.m. Reading as:

---

## Page 4

"S.H.O. Accompanied by A.S.!. Shah Muhammad, H.C. Abdul Ghafoor, H.C. Muhammad, P.C. Sobha Khan, P.C. Muhammad Aslam, P.C. Noor Muhammad, P.C. Lal Khan, P.C. ' Muhammad "Yousuf, Muhammad Muneer and Ali Nawaz left for holding patrolling and Nakabandi at Mithrao canal". The S.H.O. And Police Constables were provided one rifle with twenty bullets per head. This entry is made by H.C. Khaliluddin, and he has stated that the signatures of persons, whose names were mentioned in the Station diary, were obtained by him in token of delivery of the weapons and bullets. It is stated that six handcuffs were also given by H.C. Khaliluddin, but the Station diary does not show that the delivery of these six handcuffs was evidenced by any writing in the Station diary. It is stated that the six deceased were handcuffed with their hands behind their backs, and taken into the Police van. S.H.O. Yaqoob and A.S.I. Shah Muhammad sat in the front seat with the driver, P.C. Ghulam Qassim. This van then proceeded by metalled road to Khipro. Approver Aslam has stated that, when the van started going towards Khipro by the metalled road, he saw two jeeps following the van, and this was when the van had covered a distance of three, or four miles and reached Bakharo Mori. The topography given by approver Aslam shows that the road to Khipro starts from Bakharo Mori, but the van in which the six deceased were carried, did not proceed to Khipro, but in another direction towards. Kanan Mori. At Kanan Mori, the van stopped and the two jeeps, that were following the van, also stopped at some distance from Kanan Mori. The incident is said to have occurred at Kanan Mori. ' The story then is that S.H.O. Yaqoob and A.S.I. Shah Muhammad got down from the van, and asked all the members of the police party to get down and bring down the six prisoners, who are deceased in the case. It is stated by approver Aslam that the six deceased persons were made to stand at a distance of four to five paces from the police party, which had been divided into two parties, and each party was handed over three persons from amongst the deceased. The prisoners were made to stand at a distance of four, or, five paces from each party. It is stated that accused S.P. Ghulam Shabbir Kalyar came at the spot, and directed S.H.O. Yaqoob to shoot all the six prisoners, and, at that time, accused lmdadullah Unar and Jam Sadiq Ali were sitting in the jeep which, as stated above, was standing at some distance. The approver then states that all of them, viz he as well as the other Police Officers (excluding Kalyar) shot at the prisoners, and each one of them fell down dead. The approver is stated to have fired six shots. Thereafter, the Police party went towards the jeeps, and they found accused Ghulam Shabbir Kalyar and lmdadullah Unar, with absconder Jam Sadiq Ali, sitting in one jeep. It is stated by the approver that absconding accused Jam Sadiq Ali had a white chadar on his shoulder. In the second jeep, they saw accused Shah Nawaz Junejo and Muhammad Hassan Junejo sitting in the front seat with four other persons sitting in the back seat. These four persons are stated to be armed with guns. Thereafter, accused Muhammad Hassan Junejo came out from his jeep, and went to the other jeep, in which absconding accused Jam Sadiq Ali was sitting with accused Ghulam Shabbir Kalyar and lmdadullah Unar, and he took out some rifles, guns, pistols and leather belts, containing bullets, and thereafter accused Muhammad Hassan and Shah Nawaz Junejo went alongwith approver Aslam, Head Constable Abdul Ghafoor, P.C. Sobha Khan and S.H.O. Muhammad Yaqoob to the place, where the dead bodies of the six persons were lying. The accused, Shah Nawaz and Muhammad Hassan, fired in the air, and thereafter from out of the weapons, that had been brought out from the jeep, in which absconding accused Jam Sadiq Ali was sitting, one weapon was kept by the side of each deceased, and one belt, containing cartridges or bullets, was tied to the body of each deceased. The handcuffs were removed. It is stated that, after this was done, accused Imdadullah Unar, Ghulam Shabbir Kalyar, Shah Nawaz Junejo, Muhammad Hassan Junejo and absconder Jam Sadiq Ali left in their jeeps. Some blank papers were sent for from Sanghar Police Station, and the same were delivered by Head Constable Khaliluddin. Some blank forms of inquest reports were also obtained. A report was, thereafter, lodged at Sanghar Police Station by

---

## Page 5

S.H.O. Yaqoob Khan under sections 307, 332, P.P.C. And section 13-D of the Arms Act. This Report is Exh.53, and the same shows that Police party, consisting of S.H.O. Yaqoob and subordinate staff, namely, A.S.I. Shah Muhammad, H.C. Abdul Ghafoor, H.C. Muhammad Aslam, LNC Ali Nawaz, LNC Sobha Khan, P.C. Muhammad Muneer, P.C. Noor Muhammad, P.C. Lai Khan, P.C. Muhammad Aslam, and P.C. Muhammad Yousuf left Sanghar for patrolling and Nakabandi. That Malik Sher Muhammad and Ghulam Qadir were taken from Frontier Hotel in Sanghar town for any assistance that might be necessary. The Report states that, while patrolling, they reached Bakharo culvert, and, on 7th October, 1973, at one hour passed mid-night they formed two parties, one consisting of A.S.I. Shah Muhammad, P.C. Muhammad Aslam, LNC Ali Nawaz, P.C. Muhammad Muneer, P.C. Muhammad Yousuf, and P.C. Noor Muhammad, who went for Nakabandi on the eastern side, and the other party, consisting of S.H.O. Yaqoob, H.C. Abdul Ghafoor, Muhammad Aslam, P.C. Sobha Khan and P.C. Lal Khan on the western side. It states that, at 2.00 a.m. Shah Muhammad flashed the torch and gave a Hakal to some people to stop, introducing themselves as a Police party. They found six persons, coming towards them and even S.H.O. Muhammad Yaqoob gave a Hakal to stop, but those six persons started direct firing whereupon the Police party also opened fire in self- defence. Such firing continued for some time, but thereafter the firing by the intruders stopped, so that Police party also stopped firing. It is stated in the Report that such persons died, and they were six in number, and each one of them had a firearm, which was either rifle, or, gun, or, country-made pistol. This Report was registered by accused Mir Muhammad, an Inspector of the C.I.A., Sanghar. Dead bodies were sent for post-mortem examination, and subsequently delivered to the relatives of the deceased, namely, Sadoro and Muhammad Hassan. It is stated in the evidence of Sadoro that he, alongwith Muhammad Hassan, had gone to the hospital to identify the dead bodies, and there were black marks of beating on the bodies of the six deceased and they had buIllet injuries on their chests. ' The story then is that D.I.-G. Abdur Rahim Riasani had also come to Sanghar Police Station on 7th October, 1973 to make enquiries, and some complaints were made to him by some members of the Police party, who had actually killed the six deceased. These complaints were to the effect that they were unwilling to kill them, but had done so on account of compulsion and fear. The Deputy Inspector-General of Police told such people to keep quiet, because it was an encounter. It is stated that, within two days, each one from the party, who are alleged to be the killers of these six deceased, was given a reward, and, such amongst them, who were not confirmed in their posts, were confirmed. ' Complainant Muhammad Yaqoob, who is a disciple of Pir Sahib Pagaro, as the six deceased persons also are, read in the daily newspaper "IBRAT" on 8th October, 1973 that the six deceased persons had been killed in an encounter with the Police. He has stated that he was shocked, because four days before the publication, four out of the deceased, namely, Umad Ali, Jan Muhammad Mehrab and Lal Khan were with him. Complainant Muhammad Yaqoob then went to village Haji Jan Muhammad, where Umad Ali and Mehrab used to live, and, in that village, he met Sadoro and Muhammad Hassan. These two persons told Muhammad Yaqoob that they had gone to Sanghar on 6th October, 1973, where the case of these deceased persons under Goonda Act was pending. They also told him that a Police van came there, from which Head Constable Muhammad Aslam (the approver) came down, and thereafter the six deceased were handcuffed and taken away. Sadoro and Muhammad Hassan had also told complainant Muhammad Yaqoob that they had followed the Police party, taking away the six deceased to Police Station, and that they had enquired as to why the six deceased persons had been arrested, and that Ghazi Khan and Rakhial, who are also the followers of Pir Sahib Pagaro, were at the Police station, as they had been called for interrogation in the case of murder of Ali Bux. Sadoro and Muhammad Hassan also told complainant Muhammad Yaqoob that they had gone to the Police Station on 7th October, 1973,

---

## Page 6

where Ghazi Khan and Rakhial had informed them that, on the previous day, viz. 6th October, 1973, at sunset time, the six deceased persons had been taken out from lock-up, and thereafter taken to a room (stable) for beating. They also told him that the beating was so severe that the six deceased were crying, and thereafter, on the same night, the six deceased persons were taken away in a Police van by ten, or twelve police personnel and S.H.O. Muhammad Yaqoob, absconder Jam Sadiq Ali, accused Imdadullah Unar and accused Ghulam Shabbir Kalyar also followed the police van in a jeep. It may, however, be stated that complainant Yaqoob was related to deceased Mehrab Sanjarani. Complainant Muhammad Yaqoob, on getting such information from Sadoro and Muhammad Hassan, suspected the publication in daily "IBRAT" and he wanted to approach higher authorities to inform them about the matter. It is stated by complainant Muhammad Yaqoob that he went to the Court of Sub-Divisional Magistrate to make a complaint, but the same was not entertained, so that he came to Shahdadpur, and got an application to Inspector-General of Police written and typed. This application is Exh. 29 and is made on 11th October, 1973. In this application, disclosures made by Sadoro and Muhammad Hassan to complainant Muhammad Yaqoob are referred to. It is, however, stated that, on the evening of 6th October, 1973, the six deceased had been taken out from the lock-up for the stable behind the Police Station by S.H.O. Yaqoob, A.S.I Shah Muhammad and other Constables, and the six deceased were beaten, in spite of raising cries and entreaties not to kill them. It is then stated that "later on some doctor was also called, who declared Mehrab and Umad Ali dead and other four about to die." It then states that, thereafter, the six deceased persons were taken away to an unknown destination. It is stated in the application that the six deceased persons had been challaned in the Goonda Act cases due to political rivalries, as they were the followers of Pir Sahib Pagaro, and that they had been killed on account of political enmity. This Report was enquired into by the C.I.A. Police as well as Mr. Abdur Rahim Riasani, D.I.G. But nothing happened, so that the prosecution case is that, being a political murder, the accused were protected. However, after the proclamation of Martial Law, the complainant, Muhammad Yaqoob, made another application on 1st August, 1977 to Lt.-Gen. Jehanzeb Arbab, Martial Law Administrator Sind. This complaint is very brief and may be re- produced. It read as follows:- "My near three relations namely (1) Mehrab, (2) Umed Ali, (3) Jan Muhammad, (4) Hamzo, (5) Syed All Sher Shah and (6) Dadan, were shot dead by the Sanghar Police on 8th October, 1973, I sent a written complaint to the Inspector-General of Police Sind, Karachi, on 11th October, 1973, against the accused persons mentioned in the application. Jam Sadiq Ali, the former Minister of the Government of Sind and Muhammad Khan Junejo; the then Home Secretary of Sind, were also responsible for these murders. I also enclose herewith a copy of weekly Zindagi which contains the details of the incident given by a journalist regarding these murders". ' It may be stated that, in the issue of a weekly known as "ZINDAGI" relating to the week beginning 22nd October, 1973, and ending 28th October, 1973, a publication had appeared under the caption "Police encounter or murder incident"? In this publication, the photos of deceased persons had been published, and a suspicion had been expressed that the story of encounter with the Police was false, but, in fact, the six deceased had been murdered. This publication has been placed on record as Exh. 34. Reference to this publication has become necessary, because several witnesses have stated that they were activated to give evidence, or, make disclosures because of this publication. ' The application made by complainant Muhammad Yaqoob to Lt.-Gen. Jehanzeb Arbab was forwarded to Ansaruddin Ansari, an Assistant Director in the F.I.A. At Karachi. It was accompanied by the earlier complaint made by Muhammad Yaqoob on 11th October, 1973, as also a photo copy of weekly "Zindagi". This was registered as a Report and a case under section 302/120-B, P.P.C. (Exh. 230). The investigation was then entrusted to Haji Khuda Bux, another Assistant Director. However,

---

## Page 7

Ansaruddin Ansari examined complainant Yaqoob, Sadoro, Muhammad Hassan, Ghazi Khan and Rakhial. A further statement of complainant Yaqoob was recorded on 11th August, 1977. The Station diary of Sanghar Police Station was seized on 14th August, 1977. A.S.I. Muhammad Aslam, P.C. Muhammad Aslam, P.C. Muhammad Muneer and H.C. Abdul Ghafoor were joined in the investigation. He saw the place of incident in the presence of Mashirs Hamzo and Ghulam Mustafa. Khuda Bux, thereafter, took over the investigation. He recorded the statements of S.H:O. Muhammad Yaqoob, A.S.I. Shah Muhammad, Muhammad Aslam, Din Muhammad, Aslam son of Muhammad Ismail, Muhammad Qassim, Muhammad Muneer, Abdul Ghafoor and Noor Muhammad. All these persons were arrested on 16th August, 1977. Muhammad Aslam, approver, was sent to the Court of Mukhtiarkar and First Class Magistrate, Hyderabad, for recording his confession, and the…

Read the unabridged text and precedent citation network on Al Wakeelo Legal Research Platform.

Related Legal Research & Directories