Full Judgment Text & Judicial Ruling

1992 P L C (C

1992 P L C (C.S.) 1034

[Service Tribunal Punjab]

Present: Muhammad Mehmud Aslam Pirzada, Chairman and Abdul Hamid Khan, Member

GHULAM ABBAS

versus

ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER (CONSOLIDATION), SARGODHA and another

Appeal No. 638 of 1989, decided on 6th November, 1990.

Civil service---

---- Adverse remarks---Adverse remarks, which according to instructions for writing of A.C.R. of civil servant were to be communicated to civil servant by Reporting Officer next month after reporting same, admittedly were communicated to him after two years period of report, thus remarks against him had lost their significance---Previous as well as subsequent service record of civil servant was unblemished and adverse remarks reported against him were without any base as nothing was on record to support remarks so recorded by Reporting Officer ---During tenure of civil servant in office neither was any complaint against him nor any enquiry was ever initiated against him---Civil servant neither had absented himself from official duties nor he was ever marked absent in attendance register---Reporting Officer who had recorded adverse report in A.C.R. admittedly had given a good report to civil servant in following years---Adverse remarks recorded in A.C.R. of civil servant which otherwise had lost their significance due to violation of instructions laid down for its writing, were misconceived and unfounded-- Adverse remarks recorded in A.C.R. of civil servant were ordered to be expunged in circumstances.

Ikram Zahid for Appellant.

Manzoor Hussain, D.A. for Respondents.

Date of hearing: 30th October, 1990.

Related Legal Research & Directories

• Browse all judgments from SERVICE-TRIBUNAL-PUNJAB
• Search Pakistani statutes: Constitution of Pakistan 1973, PPC, CrPC, CPC & Family Laws
• Analyze this case with Al Wakeelo AI Legal Assistant