Al Wakeelo
Your Digital Lawyer, Always on Duty
Initializing Secure Chambers
Your Digital Lawyer, Always on Duty
Initializing Secure Chambers
Petitioner: NOOR ELAHI VS Respondent: FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN
1997 P L C (C
1997 P L C (C. S.) 8
[Supreme Court of Pakistan]
Present: Sajjad Ali Shah, C.J., and Muhammad Bashir Khan Jehangiri, J
NOOR ELAHI
versus
FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN and others ,
Constitutional Petition No. 235 of 1995, decided on 11th December, 1995:
Constitution of Pakistan' (1973)‑‑‑
‑‑‑‑Art. 212(3)‑‑‑Civil service‑‑‑Annual Confidential Report‑‑‑One adverse Annual Confidential Report throughout civil servant's career of 31 years‑‑ Validity‑‑‑Civil servant claimed that he had served for thirty‑one years but had earned only one adverse report in 1991 which was given to him by reporting officer under whom he served only for one year and who had grievance against him; and that same was communicated to him after delay of nearly four years on 15‑8‑1994 which was done in violation of paras. 15, 16‑C & 19 of Confidential Reports, P.A.F. Civilians‑‑‑Petitioner's further contention was that Annual Confidential Report was liable to be expunged‑‑‑Leave to appeal was granted to consider the contentions raised.
Petitioner in person.
Nemo for Respondents.
ORDER
It is submitted by the petitioner that he is Head Clerk in P.A.F., Sargodha, and has served for thirty‑one years but has earned only one adverse Annual Confidential Report in 1991 which was given to him by Reporting Officer, Flight Lieutenant Asim Malik, under whom he served only for one year and who had grievance against him. It is further .submitted that this adverse A.C.R. of 1991 was communicated to him after a delay of nearly four years on 15‑8‑1994 which was done in violation of paragraphs 15, 16‑C and 19 of Confidential Reports, PAF Civilians. It is contended that in the circumstances the said A.C.R. is liable to be expunged. Leave is granted to consider the contention stated above.
A.A./M‑472/S Leave granted