Al Wakeelo
Your Digital Lawyer, Always on Duty
Initializing Secure Chambers
Your Digital Lawyer, Always on Duty
Initializing Secure Chambers
Petitioner: PUNJAB URBAN TRANSPORT CORPORATION VS Respondent: MUHAMMAD ALI
Court Name: Labour Appellate Tribunal Judge(s): Sardar Muhammad Abdul Ghafoor Khan Lodhi Title: PUNJAB URBAN TRANSPORT CORPORATION vs MUHAMMAD ALI Case No.: Appeal No, LHR-725 of 1984 Date of Judgment:1985-02-22 Reported As: 1985 PLC 780 Result: Appeal dismissed
JUDGMENT
JUDGMENT ' The decision dated 18th November, 1984 recorded by the learned Presiding Officer, Punjab Labour Court No, 1, Lahore has been challenged, whereby Muhammad Ali, respondent, was directed to be restored to his original position as S. T. E. And T. E. With full back benefits. 2. On account of abolition of the posts of S. T. Es. And T. Es. The respondent, who was an S. T. E. Was reverted to the post of conductor. He challenged the reversion before the learned lower Court. 3. It has been argued by the learned counsel for the appellant that a writ is pending, therefore, the learned lower Court's order is not maintainable. On the face of it the argument is without force. Since no stay order is alleged to have been issued by the High Court, the case had to be disposed of by the learned lower Court one way or the other. The appellant did not order reversion in accordance with seniority list. According to Exh. R. 4, the persons mentioned at serial Nos, 1, 4, 5 to 9 and 18 are junior to the respondent but they were retained as S. T. E. And the respondent was reverted. Qamar Din, Iqbal Hussain, Taj Muhammad and Sh. Muhammad Akbar were working as Inspectors on 5th December, 1981 when the respondent was reverted. They too are junior to the respondent. If at all for some reasons best known to the appellant, the respondent could not be retained as S. T. E., he should have been reverted as Inspector and not as a conductor. So the impugned order of the learned lower Court is correct and needs no interference. 4. As a result, the appeal fails and is dismissed.