DISTRICT MANAGER, GOVERNMENT TRANSPORT SERVICE, HYDERABAD vs — 1972 PLC 377

Citation: 1972 PLC 377

Court: Labour Court

Year: 1971

Decision Date: 1971-05-26

Parties: DISTRICT MANAGER, GOVERNMENT TRANSPORT SERVICE, HYDERABAD vs MUHAMMAD BAKHSH

Headnotes

Case cited as 1972 PLC 377

Judgment Text

Court Name: Labour Court Judge(s): Shoukat Ali A. Nanji, Hidayat Hussain Title:DISTRICT MANAGER, GOVERNMENT TRANSPORT SERVICE, HYDERABAD vs MUHAMMAD BAKHSH Case No.: Application No. 86 of 1968 Date of Judgment:1971-05-26 Reported As: 1972 PLC 377 Result: N/A Judgment DECISION HIDAYAT HUSSAIN (CHAIRMAN).-On 7th May 1968, a checking party consisting of Station Superintendent S. M. Saqib and Traffic Assistant Ummaid Ali checked Bus No. 2125 at Tando Muhammad Khan. Respondent Muhammad Bux was the Con--ductor and he did not issue tickets although he had realized the fare. Domestic enquiry was conducted against the respondent wherein Traffic Assistant Ummaid Ali was examined. The respon--dent examined himself and his witness Noor Muhammad Shah. Enquiry Officer found the charges against the respondent as proved hence this application for permission to dismiss the respondent. Mr. Aley Muhammad appears for the respondent. His contentions are as follows:- (a) During the domestic enquiry, the Traffic Assistant Ummaid Ali only was examined and he was biased against the respondent. (b) The original tickets which are alleged to have been issued by the Checking Party have not been brought on record. (c) The respondent had issued tickets to all the passengers and this may be verified by T. T. 2 Form. Traffic Assistant Ummaid Ali was cross-examined by the respondent to the enquiry proceedings and he did not allege any bias against him at that stage. Moreover, the witness Noor Muhammad Shah…

Read the full judgment on Al Wakeelo — Pakistan's AI-powered legal research platform.